[TheBigFourFTW]

I recently made a thread pitting hypothetical scenarios pitting grand slam finalists at that year and tournament, and I thought it would be fun to make another thread again about.



Part 1: http://www.menstennisforums.com/showthread.php?t=598506





In your opinion, who would win between these finalists (at the time they played) if they pit against each other and in how many sets? Give reasons too.





Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling



US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2014 Nishikori



Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick



Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal



Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray



US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick



US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic



Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic



Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin

 

[Phenomenadal]

Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling: Ferrer vultured his way to the final. Soderking took out the FO Goat.

US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2013 Nishikori: Nishikori to fade in the final.

Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick: It's Federer on grass.

Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal: Roddick is a more complete player.

Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray: 2008 Tsonga can play like Roger, it's a shame he can't cry like him.

US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick: Agassi knows how to beat other Americans.

US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic: Constant Tweener passing shots.

Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic: Despite illness, Djokovic routines the field.

Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin: It takes the GOAT to knockout this Safin.

 

[BackhandDTL]

Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling: Soderling in 4 (basically their 2009 meeting but easier).

US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2013 Nishikori: Djokovic in 4.

Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick: Roddick in 4.

Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal: Roddick in 5.

Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray: Tsonga, I think, in 4.

US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick: Agassi in 4.

US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic: Federer in 3.

Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic: Djokovic in 5.

Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin: Safin, maybe, in 5.

 

[InfoKenway]

Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling: Soderling in 4

US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2013 Nishikori: Djokovic in 3. In 2013 Nishikori lost to Evans :lol:

Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick: Roddick in 3.

Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal: Nadal in 4.

Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray: Murray in 4.

US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick: Roddick in 4.

US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic: Federer in 3.

Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic: Djokovic in 4.

Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin: 50/50

 

[Matthew2408]

2013 Nishikori lost to Dan Evans?


Sent from Verticalsports.com Free App

 

[TheBigFourFTW]

Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling: Soderling in 4



US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2013 Nishikori: Djokovic in 3. In 2013 Nishikori lost to Evans :lol:



Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick: Roddick in 3.



Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal: Nadal in 4.



Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray: Murray in 4.



US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick: Roddick in 4.



US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic: Federer in 3.



Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic: Djokovic in 4.



Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin: 50/50

2013 Nishikori lost to Dan Evans?


Sent from Verticalsports.com Free App

My mistake. Was meant to put down Nishikori 2014 for US Open. You guys still have the same prediction + sets?


Sent from Verticalsports.com Free App

 

[norwood_10]

Roland Garros 2013 Ferrer vs Roland Garros 2009 Soderling

Soderling in 3


US Open 2010 Djokovic vs US Open 2014 Nishikori

Djokovic in 4



Wimbledon 2008 Federer vs Wimbledon 2004 Roddick



Wimbledon 2009 Roddick vs Wimbledon 2007 Nadal

Nadal in 4



Australian Open 2008 Tsonga vs Australian Open 2010 Murray

Tsonga in 5



US Open 2005 Aggasi vs US Open 2006 Roddick

Agassi in 4


US Open 2009 Federer vs US Open 2007 Djokovic

Federer in 4



Roland Garros 2004 Coria vs Roland Garros 2014 Djokovic

Djokovic in 5


Australian Open 2007 Gonzalez vs Australian Open 2004 Safin

Gonzalez in 5