It's surely Hewitt because in the last 6 Slams he was stopped near the final by the eventual winner
Who would have won the Slams Federer won if Federer wasn't around to win them?
I am new to this board and thought I should start it with an (interesting) thread so I did after I suddenly came up upon a question.
If in all the 5 Grand Slams that Federer won Federer would have been injured or just not there, who would have won them? One might say: the person he beat in the final, but if you look at the last Wimbledons for instance then you can see a guy like Hewitt or Gonzales might have gotten that final spot and beaten Roddick like there is no tomorrow...
But anyway, I was wondering. I will give my own opinion later
If in all the 5 Grand Slams that Federer won Federer would have been injured or just not there, who would have won them? One might say: the person he beat in the final, but if you look at the last Wimbledons for instance then you can see a guy like Hewitt or Gonzales might have gotten that final spot and beaten Roddick like there is no tomorrow...
But anyway, I was wondering. I will give my own opinion later
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
roddick, and you know it
3 wimby? I dont think Karlovic would have lost if Federer wasn't around that tourney?oneandonlyhsn said:
I would switch Wimb 2004 and 2005 around actually.. I think Hewitt was a lot stronger in 2004 wimby than 2005. but as you said, your own opinionWinston's Human said:
I might as well give mine now cause I am going to eat now.
Wimb 2003 - forgot about that one, such a long time ago. Would probably have been Roddick indeed.
AO 2004 - Ferrero...I think Safin was way too tired in that final to make it hard for anyone?
Wimb 2004 - Hewitt. Hewitt played out of his mind that tournament. Hewitt - Federer I think was still of the best matches I ever watched...Hewitt rocked, he so should have made that a 5th set. Roddick wasnt good that tourney. Only in the final he gave Federer a bit of a scare
US2004 - Hewitt for sure
Wimb 2005 - I'd also say Hewitt, although I give Roddick a better shot than in 2004.
USOpen 2005 - Hewitt I think. (Federer will win this and beat Hewitt again...)
The reason I came up with this question is Hewitt really...If Federer wouldnt have been around I think Hewitt would have dominated the game himself...Although, as all the players say, Federer has lifted everybody's game really. hewitt is now better than 3 years ago, solely because of Federer. Same for all the other players.
The sarcasm on this board is ridiculous
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
