You can't even call Sinner/Alcaraz a "rivalry" its been a one sided beatdown for 2-3 years basically and especially the last 2 season its been ALL Carlos except for Wimbledon this year. Alcaraz has completely dismantled/exposed him outside of Wimbledon this year. Fed kept his hardcourt slams protected from 05-08 and took out Nadal back to back at Wimbledon in 06/07. If Carlos takes the AO, i would say its pretty much over for Sinner

 

Federer was hopeless against Nadal on clay (especially RG), Sinner isn't against Alcaraz
Sincaraz is way more unpredictable than Fedal during 2005-2014

 

Fedal was a lop sided rivalry from 2008 to 2016 until Federer ran riot in 2017. Only counting their good years (2008-2019 minus 2013 and 2015), their h2h stands 11-9 in favor of Nadal and that is not one-sided at all. The overall h2h is somewhat one-sided (24-16).

The Sincaraz rivalry is still young and both players have long careers ahead of them. Currently, Alcaraz leads 7-1 (since 2024 when they both primed) and Sinner will have to win a lot to make it competitive. The overall h2h is 9-5 and percentage wise, this is worse when compared to Fedal.

For now, Fedal is the more competitive of the two rivalries.

 

Nadal statspadded H2H over Federer due to clay-skew and 2013-skew. Federer has winning H2H on 2/3 surfaces.

 

DULL statpadded like crazy against GOATerers injured years

 

Sincaraz is actually way more competitive

 

Being 5 years younger, it automatically means Rafa stats padded against Olderer doesn't it?