Mens Tennis Forums banner

1 - 20 of 90 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,004 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Let us consider a hypothetical situation where the Big 3 face off at the four slams+WTF multiple times and all are at the peak of the powers. Who wins how many times if 4 matches are played at each slam between each pair? Discuss. (no need for answers which are illogical/tardish)

My analysis->

Australian Open


Assuming Plexicushion surface

1. 2011ovic vs Nadal in AO 2009 form: I would say a 2-2 tie seems most likely

2. 2011ovic vs 2005-07erer: 3-1 Djokovic, on plexicushion in peak form, Djokovic > Federer with his insane defence

3. 2005-07erer vs Nadal in AO 2009 form: Would go for 3-1 Nadal here, we saw what happened in 2009, and I would argue that Federer was playing at almost his peak level in that match (bar the serve)

French Open


1. 2008/2012 Nadal vs 2011ovic: 3-1 Nadal, I daresay 2011 Djokovic could have beaten Nadal atleast once at FO

2. 2008/2012 Nadal vs 2006erer/2011erer: 4-0 Nadal :wavey:

3. 2006erer/2011erer vs 2011ovic: 2-2 seems most likely with both rivals trading wins

Wimbledon

2005-06erer vs 2008 Nadal: 3-1 Federer IMO, his performance in his 2006 final was just fantastic against his worst matchup

2005-06erer vs 2011ovic: 4-0 Federer :wavey:

2008 Nadal vs 2011ovic: Pretty confused here due to lack of data to extrapolate from. Probably 2-2 seems most likely

US Open


2004erer vs 2011ovic: Would be a rivalry for the ages with 3-1 Federer

2004erer vs 2010/2013 version Nadal: No data to comment, but 2-2 most likely

2010/2013 version Nadal vs 2011ovic: Going with 3-1 Nadal. When his serve is on and his FHDTL is working, Djokovic can't do much

WTF

2003-2011erer vs 2010 Nadal: 4-0 :wavey:

2003-2011erer vs 2012ovic: 3-1 IMO

2012ovic vs 2010 Nadal: 3-1

Overall H2H

Federer-Nadal: 10-10
Federer-Djokovic: 13-7
Djokovic Nadal: 9-11

Federer vs Djokodal: 23-17 :worship: :GOAT:
Nadal vs Nolerer: 21:19 :worship:
Djokovic vs Fedal 16:24 :wavey:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,284 Posts
I don't think I need to do my analysis because I totally agree with every single thing you said Mr. President, every thing. My answers would be exactly the same.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,734 Posts
US Open



2010/2013 version Nadal vs 2011ovic: Going with 3-1 Nadal. When his serve is on and his FHDTL is working, Djokovic can't do much
What? Djokovic still took a set from Nadal in one of his worst years.

It's most likely 3-1 2011ovic.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,535 Posts
No way 2011ovic would be 2-2 against dull at AO. Are u crazy?. Imo. 4-0

:spit: Again no way nadal would be 3-1 against 2011ovic at USO. Both times dull beat him he was playing horrible, in 2010 he had his worse season as top player. Honestly can't compare 2010/13 djokovic to 2011. Imo 3-1
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,734 Posts
No way 2011ovic would be 2-2 against dull at AO. Are u crazy?. Imo. 4-0

:spit: Again no way nadal would be 3-1 against 2011ovic at USO. Both times dull beat him he was playing horrible, in 2010 he had his worse season as top player. Honestly can't compare 2010/13 djokovic to 2011. Imo 3-1
Well, Murray took him to 5 sets, Nadal almost won against him, so 2-2 it's possible, but more likely 3-1 Djokovic there too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,025 Posts
AO :
Nadal vs Djokovic 0-4
Federer vs Nadal 2-2
Djokovic vs Federer 3-1

RG :
Nadal vs Djokovic 3-1
Federer vs Nadal 0-4
Djokovic vs Federer 1-3

W :
Nadal vs Djokovic 2-2
Federer vs Nadal 3-1
Djokovic vs Federer 0-4

USO :
Nadal vs Djokovic 1-3
Federer vs Nadal 2-2
Djokovic vs Federer 1-3

WTF :
Nadal vs Djokovic 0-4
Federer vs Nadal 4-0
Djokovic vs Federer 1-3
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,535 Posts
Well, Murray took him to 5 sets, Nadal almost won against him, so 2-2 it's possible, but more likely 3-1 Djokovic there too.
That was 2012 bro, I was talking about 2011ovic vs 2009 nadal

Love the username, F.R.I.E.N.D.S the best comedy ever.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,004 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
No way 2011ovic would be 2-2 against dull at AO. Are u crazy?. Imo. 4-0

:spit: Again no way nadal would be 3-1 against 2011ovic at USO. Both times dull beat him he was playing horrible, in 2010 he had his worse season as top player. Honestly can't compare 2010/13 djokovic to 2011. Imo 3-1
The kind of insane form Dull had at AO 2009 , it is not out of the question to assume that at the very least he would be 2-2 with any version of Djokovic at AO
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,004 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
No way 2011ovic would be 2-2 against dull at AO. Are u crazy?. Imo. 4-0

:spit: Again no way nadal would be 3-1 against 2011ovic at USO. Both times dull beat him he was playing horrible, in 2010 he had his worse season as top player. Honestly can't compare 2010/13 djokovic to 2011. Imo 3-1
You could also make the case that dull was horrible at 2011 USO which caused Djokovic's easy 4 set win. Dude when Nadal's sampras serve is working and his FHDTL is working, it become very difficult for Djokovic regardless of his own form. I would say worst case 2-2 between them, but not 3-1 Djokovic , no
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,734 Posts
That was 2012 bro, I was talking about 2011ovic vs 2009 nadal

Love the username, F.R.I.E.N.D.S the best comedy ever.
:worship: :cool: 100% True.

There wasn't really a big difference with 2011ovic and Djokovic at AO 2012. He wasn't that great anymore, but still pretty great.

Never count Nadal out but yeah, Djokovic would most likely be 3-1/4-0 at AO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,025 Posts
You could also make the case that dull was horrible at 2011 USO which caused Djokovic's easy 4 set win. Dude when Nadal's sampras serve is working and his FHDTL is working, it become very difficult for Djokovic regardless of his own form. I would say worst case 2-2 between them, but not 3-1 Djokovic , no
The same Nadal that destroyed Roddick and Murray ? :lol:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,535 Posts
The kind of insane form Dull had at AO 2009 , it is not out of the question to assume that at the very least he would be 2-2 with any version of Djokovic at AO
He was pushed to the limit in this tournament, barely scraped through his matches against verdasco and fed. Meanwhile djokovic droped one set the whole entire tournament. Imo 2011ovic 4-0 2009 nadal
 

·
Federer Fan & Dull Hater
Joined
·
11,399 Posts
AO

Federer - Novak: 2-2
Federer - Dull: 4-0
Novak - Dull: 4-0

FO

Federer - Novak: 3-1
Federer - Dull: 0-4
Novak - Dull: 3-1

Wimbledon:

Federer - Novak: 4-0
Federer - Dull: 4-0
Novak - Dull: 4-0

USO:

Federer - Novak: 4-0
Federer - Dull: 4-0
Novak - Dull: 4-0

WTF:

Federer - Novak: 3-1
Federer - Dull: 4-0
Novak - Dull: 4-0
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,284 Posts
:worship: :cool: 100% True.

There wasn't really a big difference with 2011ovic and Djokovic at AO 2012. He wasn't that great anymore, but still pretty great.

Never count Nadal out but yeah, Djokovic would most likely be 3-1/4-0 at AO.
Well I would say Djokovic was definitely better in the AO 2011 than in AO 2012. Both were great but AO 2011 was higher in level of play. That AO 2011 was an insane tournament for Djokovic, arguably the highest level he ever played in a tournament. and I think that's the tournament in which nolethebest exactly referring too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,535 Posts
You could also make the case that dull was horrible at 2011 USO which caused Djokovic's easy 4 set win. Dude when Nadal's sampras serve is working and his FHDTL is working, it become very difficult for Djokovic regardless of his own form. I would say worst case 2-2 between them, but not 3-1 Djokovic , no

:spit: cut the crap man. Dull was horrible at 2011 USO? he played better that year than he did in 2013 and would have won everything in sight if wasn't for djokovic.

As for dull FHDTL, it mostly effective on clay and you could make the same case for djokovic as well with his Bh DTL and his BH CC, when it's working dull look so clueless.
 
1 - 20 of 90 Posts
Top