I understand that people had even less of a clue about transsexuality in the '70's than they do today, but the theory that a guy would be desperate enough to weasle into the women's tour to cut his bits off is ridiculous.
i think i would have played the match too in that situation.
i think on that tv program it was betty stove who spoke out that it might create a lot of transexuals playing on the ladies tour, but she seems to be wrong since there are zero as far as I know.
Renee Richards actually got pretty far up the rankings, if memory serves. I'll do some research. But I seem to recall she may hae gotten as high as #10 for a couple weeks. That's NOT a fact. That's a very foggy memory. I'll hunt around.
Keep in mind that "man" had been chemically (and probably surgically) castrated years before playing in the WTA. That hormone therapy would have removed most if not all of the physical advantage "he" might have possessed.
fwiw/imo - whether or not you think RR should have been allowed to play in the WTA, if this person felt so strongly that they were truly a woman trapped in a male body, that the physical form was an error, that they were willing to undergo such a radical, traumatic and even dangerous transformation, the least we can do is respect HER decision and stop referring to her as "he" or as a man. Renee Richards would probably tell you she is not a man who became a woman, but a woman who after many years was able to have her outer form reflect who she really was all along.
no, she is a woman only something went wrong with the conception that's not her fault!
when I was little I often thought, shoot I would feel awful when I was a boy(I didn't even want to wear trousers because of that), now I was born in the right body so no problems for me there but the idea horrified me for some reason so I can only be glad things went right
so I am not in the positions to judge people who went through this hell!
No, I would play the human being that was set to play me. Personally it would be more important to me as an person and an opponent to want to make sure that Renee didn't feel discriminated against on a tennis court.
Personally I can't understand the feelings she must have felt, but there's not reason as to why she shouldn't be allowed ot play on the WTA Tour. Do you actually think when she was Richard "Hey! If I become a woman maybe I'd be better on the WTA?" NO. She felt trapped, like Griffin said, and you have to be able to accept and respect her decision. If I were a woman(god forbid) I'd play Renee.
Renee didn't dominate so she had no advantage obviously. I disagree disposable because just because Renee was previously a man does not mean that her body type was an advantage when she became a women. Seriously if she were my opponent right now, I would not begrudge her the chance to play me. I just think that if someone didn't want to play Renee, it would have nothing to do with the fact that she use to be a man, and her body type would be and unfair advantage. I think it would be because people don't want a transexual on the tour. So for that reason, I say let her play.
This is a debatable subject though.
Good thread anton.
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.