[Mark Lenders]

So I think it's more or less agreed Federer, Nadal and Djokovic are top 3 peak level wise, but who'd come next among active players?

I think del Potro, but let's see what MTF thinks. Achivement-wise, Hewitt would be next in line of course.

 

[Master Yoda]

Wawrinka

 

[Tutsi Frutsi]

1. Wawrinka
2. Murray
3. Nishikori
4. Tsonga
5. Del Potro
6. Soderling
7. Cilic
8. Hewitt

 

[Fogmeister]

Golubev by far. He's absolutely unplayable at his peak.

 

[Basher]

I voted delpo, mainly because I feel that his average level was already way up there as well, but really all these guys can play insane tennis at times.

 

[TigerTim]

Hewitt vs. Serve and Volley.

 

[Logos]

USO14 Cilic - unleashed the Kraken.:worship:

 

[Chris Kuerten]

You forgot Ferrer in the poll.

 

[Fastgrass]

Stan rbelow Birdshit in poll? :facepalm:

Answer is Stan, we all know that.

 

[Federer-Fan]

It depends on the surface and what do you mean by peak level. If we're talking about a season, I'd go with peak Murray for sure. On a tournament alone, definitely del Potro or Murray. On a single match, probably Tsonga.

 

[TBkeeper]

Davydenko's peak >>> Del Po's peak

 

[Chris Kuerten]

Stan rbelow Birdshit in poll? :facepalm:

Answer is Stan, we all know that.

You are not very good at this.

 

[DjokoKing]

Wawrinka, unfortunately.

 

[Chris Kuerten]

Davydenko's peak >>> Del Po's peak

That's strange, because Del Potro won a slam beating Nadal and Federer back to back, while Davydenko always shat himself against Federer in the slams and never even got close.

 

[Mark Lenders]

USO14 Cilic - unleashed the Kraken.:worship:

That's a good call. He was the only one who managaed to not drop any set in the last 3 matches of a Slam (aside from the big 3), only one tiebreak too.

 

[BodyServe]

Golubev by far. He's absolutely unplayable at his peak.

This is actually a great answer :yeah:

Don't forget Goatsol too, his dismantling of Bautista Agut at the french open was one of the most impressive performance i have ever seen.

 

[TigerTim]

That's strange, because Del Potro won a slam beating Nadal and Federer back to back, while Davydenko always shat himself against Federer in the slams and never even got close.

but but but

Davydenko beat Nadal in the Shanghai Masters final !

also Nadal was injured

and he beat Del Potro in the WTF final.

 

[BodyServe]

Cilic dismantling of Federer at the US Open was one of the all time great performance too.

 

[Fogmeister]

This is actually a great answer :yeah:

Don't forget Goatsol too, his dismantling of Bautista Agut at the french open was one of the most impressive performance i have ever seen.

Yeah, goatsol has an awesome peak too.

The man in your avatar also would be a good asnwer. Peak Karlovic is obviously unplayable (2nd set against Federer in Basel's SF last year).

None of those players Lenderss put as options in the thread are unplayable at their peaks. Among those, I'd say Wawrinka or Delpo.

 

[Moozza]

Murray at his best beats everyone on that list.