Rafter, though I reckon he has retired as it's now Dec & there's no mention of him comping back next year.
In the past for me it was Edberg. Suppose McEnroe was up there as well, but he was never on my top list. Becker wasn't bad, but he was pretty unorthodox with it.
Meaningless poll, me thinks.. Serve&volleyers is a certain category of players, so it's not that we need to compare one single component of their games, we just need to compare their game as a whole thing. And then there is one simple way to compare - just find the best of them measuring tem by their success.
Notice Bjorkman has had no votes (or not enough to count anyway) and see that has been proved today as he is still an active player, whereas Edberg has been retired for several years. Yet he still beat Jonas today in an exhibition match - think the score was 6-3 4-6 10-8 (champion's tiebreak). Think that proves Stefan is the superior s & v player even today!!!
Pete has the best serve, but Rafter has the best volley. I think to be a serve-volleyer you have to have a good serve, having a good serve doesnt make you any less a serve-volleyer, it just makes it more efficient. I dont get why people say Rafters serve was nothing much, it was a very good serve, much better than Henmans anyway. So I will go with Rafter as he has good serves and good volleys.