Who wld be the Goat if Tennis only had one serve and each and every serve is like a 2nd serve..The results of Roland garros wld be somewhat same as Serve is not a deciding factor there..
Wimbledon- The biggest question mark..As Sampras and Federer wld not have won as many titles as they have...
I'll go first:
This is all subjective, of course, but this is how I rate their shots...
Not sure if we had a thread about this, but let's talk about the absolute peak level of tennis displayed by the members of the big 3. When did you think they reached their absolute peak? The poll is included.
PS You might want to break it down into several categories such as physicality...
With Hilmy having not played any competitive matches for many months and certain to be unseeded, will he create havoc for one of the Big 3 in early rounds? Will his on court demeanour change back to normal now that the threat of suspension has been lifted? Can he handle Bof5 without match...
Which player? Poll will be for the AO.
At AO: I think Novak
Then the rest may depend on who hasn't won one yet, but independently I would say.
At RG: I think RAFA
At Wimbledon: I think Roger
At the US Open? Again, whomever hasn't won one yet, but probably Novak, if he is still behind...