Who will be considered as a better player: Davydenko vs Nalbandian? - Page 13 - MensTennisForums.com

MensTennisForums.com

MenstennisForums.com is the premier Men's Tennis forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.Please Register - It's Free!

View Poll Results: Who will be considered as a better player: Davydenko vs Nalbandian?

Davydenko 8 28.57%
Nalbandian 18 64.29%
Can't split them 2 7.14%
Voters: 28. You may not vote on this poll

Reply

Old 05-05-2013, 01:17 AM   #181
country flag BauerAlmeida
Registered User
 
BauerAlmeida's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Argentina
Age: 22
Posts: 3,875
BauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

I think David was a bit superior. Both in terms of career and peak level.

I think Haas vs Davydenko would be a good comparison.
BauerAlmeida is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 

Old 05-05-2013, 01:22 AM   #182
country flag Mark Lenders
Registered User
 
Mark Lenders's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Lisbon, Portugal
Posts: 12,740
Mark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by BauerAlmeida View Post
I think David was a bit superior. Both in terms of career and peak level.

I think Haas vs Davydenko would be a good comparison.
In terms of career, it'd be a pretty pointless comparison.

Davydenko WTF/TMC winner > Haas hasn't even played in the year-end event ever

Davydenko 3 Masters 1000 > Haas 1

21 titles > 13

Also far more stability as a top player.


I suppose we could argue about peak level, but career wise Davydenko has done much, much better. Haas does have a Olympic silver medal going for him though, forgot that.

Last edited by Mark Lenders : 05-05-2013 at 01:26 AM.
Mark Lenders is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:25 AM   #183
country flag Honestly
Registered User
 
Honestly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2012
Age: 30
Posts: 5,388
Honestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by hipolymer View Post
I'll go with Nalbandian because he didn't choke to Federer as much as Davydenko did. Nalbandian was also affected by injuries much more so I'll give his superiority the benefit of the doubt.
Davydenko didn't choke. He got outplayed. Hence Fat Dave is the winner here.
__________________
BOAT
4-1-7-5-6
Career slam
302 weeks at #1
7 Wimbledon titles
10 consecutive slam F, 23 consecutive slam SF, 36 consecutive slam QF
3/4 slam titles on 3 occasions, 4/4 slam finals on 3 occasions
4 consecutive Laureus sportsman of the year awards
Proving the haters wrong...priceless
Honestly is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:32 AM   #184
country flag rocketassist
Banned!
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 25,682
rocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by Honestly View Post
Davydenko didn't choke. He got outplayed. Hence Fat Dave is the winner here.
Not always.

USO 06 and 07 Fed thumped him, but AO 06 and 10 Denko was in charge of both matches and shit his pants.
rocketassist is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:35 AM   #185
country flag Mark Lenders
Registered User
 
Mark Lenders's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Lisbon, Portugal
Posts: 12,740
Mark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by rocketassist View Post
Not always.

USO 06 and 07 Fed thumped him, but AO 06 and 10 Denko was in charge of both matches and shit his pants.
He was a bit unlucky to always be in Federer's half for hardcourt Slams (and even FO), could have finals otherwise. His best chance was AO 2007 when he was in Rafa's half; he lost 7-5 in the fifth to Haas in the QF. Had he made it through that one, I'd favor him to beat Gonzalez (despite Gonzo's form) since it's a highly favorable matchup for him.
Mark Lenders is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:51 AM   #186
country flag BauerAlmeida
Registered User
 
BauerAlmeida's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Argentina
Age: 22
Posts: 3,875
BauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Lenders View Post
In terms of career, it'd be a pretty pointless comparison.

Davydenko WTF/TMC winner > Haas hasn't even played in the year-end event ever

Davydenko 3 Masters 1000 > Haas 1

21 titles > 13

Also far more stability as a top player.


I suppose we could argue about peak level, but career wise Davydenko has done much, much better. Haas does have a Olympic silver medal going for him though, forgot that.
Yes. Of course Davy's career was better, but Haas' career was destroyed by injuries. In peak level they're close and also in terms of consistency (considering when Haas could stay injury-free for a relatively long period of time).
BauerAlmeida is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:51 AM   #187
country flag Johnny Groove
Future ATP Star
 
Johnny Groove's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: South Florida
Age: 24
Posts: 34,985
Johnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond reputeJohnny Groove has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Davydenko more steady overall week in and week out.

Peak level was obviously Nalbandian.

Dave had a 7-5 H2H lead overall.

__________________
Respect the Laws of MTF
Brush up on your tennis history, people- Top 101 Tennis Players of all Time
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nathaliia View Post
What do you like doing on MTF most?
Reading Johnny Groove threads.

Quote:
Originally Posted by tripwires View Post
Johnny blurs the line between grandeur and grandiose
Johnny Groove is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 01:55 AM   #188
country flag Honestly
Registered User
 
Honestly's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2012
Age: 30
Posts: 5,388
Honestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond reputeHonestly has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by rocketassist View Post
Not always.

USO 06 and 07 Fed thumped him, but AO 06 and 10 Denko was in charge of both matches and shit his pants.
AO 10 Fed played unbelievable to come back, 06 I don't remember.
__________________
BOAT
4-1-7-5-6
Career slam
302 weeks at #1
7 Wimbledon titles
10 consecutive slam F, 23 consecutive slam SF, 36 consecutive slam QF
3/4 slam titles on 3 occasions, 4/4 slam finals on 3 occasions
4 consecutive Laureus sportsman of the year awards
Proving the haters wrong...priceless
Honestly is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:01 AM   #189
country flag rocketassist
Banned!
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 25,682
rocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond reputerocketassist has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by Honestly View Post
AO 10 Fed played unbelievable to come back, 06 I don't remember.
He played well towards the end of the match but Davydenko from having bp's for *4-1 went into complete and utter meltdown until 2-6 6-3 3-0 and then Fed played excellently from there IIRC, with Davy at least recovering in the 4th.
rocketassist is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:01 AM   #190
country flag vpmrosulate
Registered User
 
vpmrosulate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 1,564
vpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Love both, but judging by those stats alone, I'd go with Nalbandian in most respects. Davydenko's finals record (and possibly career) is far better, but a lot of the finals are 250's, so considering just the biggest tournaments, there isn't a huge difference between their achievements. In terms of being well-rounded surface-wise, Nalbandian has done more on grass, and was a threat on any surface. His Madrid and Paris runs were hugely impressive, good indicators of peak level, and the fact that he didn't sustain that kind of level more often is unfortunate. Oh, and then there's the H2H in favor of Nalbandian.

I didn't realize before that Davydenko never made a slam final...
__________________
Players I support for non-tennis reasons: Murray/Ferrer/Monaco/Nadal/Isner/Li

del Potro/Nalbandian/Safin
Gulbis/Monfils/Dolgopolov/Tursunov/Giorgi
Davydenko/Janowicz/Verdasco/Lopez
Soderling/Cilic/Blake
vpmrosulate is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:09 AM   #191
country flag Mark Lenders
Registered User
 
Mark Lenders's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Lisbon, Portugal
Posts: 12,740
Mark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by BauerAlmeida View Post
Yes. Of course Davy's career was better, but Haas' career was destroyed by injuries. In peak level they're close and also in terms of consistency (considering when Haas could stay injury-free for a relatively long period of time).
I agree with this. That said, I made the comparison between Davydenko and Nalbandian because their achievements are very similar imo.

Davydenko has a slight edge in terms of first tier titles (3 Masters + WTF > 2 Masters + WTF), although Nalbandian's M1000 title runs were more memorable, and overall titles. He was also generally more consistent and lasted longer as a top player (until his wrist injury in 2010 really). But Nalbandian has the edge at Slams with a final and semis at all 4 Slams, and many would argue that he has a higher peak level.

They are in the same tier as players who did almost everything they could do in their careers bar winning a Slam - they have titles in all other categories really.

Last edited by Mark Lenders : 05-05-2013 at 02:12 AM.
Mark Lenders is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:15 AM   #192
country flag Arakasi
Registered User
 
Arakasi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 798
Arakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond reputeArakasi has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

I think in terms of career achievements Davydenko edges it for me. That finals record is fantastic and he maintained a consistent ranking for a long time.

It's also worth noting that Davydenko lost to Federer in 3 slam semifinals and 2 quarterfinals whereas Nalbandian only played him in one semi. Without that obstacle he'd easily have a few slam finals. He was also cheated in his only other semi when he lost to doping Puerta.

Last edited by Arakasi : 05-05-2013 at 02:17 AM.
Arakasi is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:24 AM   #193
country flag vpmrosulate
Registered User
 
vpmrosulate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 1,564
vpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond reputevpmrosulate has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by Arakasi View Post
I think in terms of career achievements Davydenko edges it for me. That finals record is fantastic and he maintained a consistent ranking for a long time.

It's also worth noting that Davydenko lost to Federer in 3 slam semifinals and 2 quarterfinals whereas Nalbandian only played him in one semi. Without that obstacle he'd easily have a few slam finals. He was also cheated in his only other semi when he lost to doping Puerta.
I'm not sure. Obviously Federer is a very tough opponent for anyone, especially in slams, but Davydenko lost to Federer just as much outside the slams (2-19 overall) whereas Nalbandian was a decent 8-11 against him. I'm not saying that with Davydenko's draw, Nalbandian would have done much better, but certainly at least somewhat better.
__________________
Players I support for non-tennis reasons: Murray/Ferrer/Monaco/Nadal/Isner/Li

del Potro/Nalbandian/Safin
Gulbis/Monfils/Dolgopolov/Tursunov/Giorgi
Davydenko/Janowicz/Verdasco/Lopez
Soderling/Cilic/Blake
vpmrosulate is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 02:28 AM   #194
country flag Mark Lenders
Registered User
 
Mark Lenders's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Lisbon, Portugal
Posts: 12,740
Mark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond reputeMark Lenders has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by vpmrosulate View Post
I'm not sure. Obviously Federer is a very tough opponent for anyone, especially in slams, but Davydenko lost to Federer just as much outside the slams (2-19 overall) whereas Nalbandian was a decent 8-11 against him. I'm not saying that with Davydenko's draw, Nalbandian would have done much better, but certainly at least somewhat better.
Nalbandian definitely matched up better vs Federer, would have probably won the RG 2006 semi if not for injury and beat Fed twice at a Slam and in the final of the WTF. That only makes his failure to win a Slam stand out even more though, as Federer was by far the biggest obstacle and one that he could negotiate unlike Davydenko (not to mention he also matches up well vs Nadal).
Mark Lenders is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 05-05-2013, 04:10 AM   #195
country flag ballbasher101
Registered User
 
ballbasher101's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Age: 27
Posts: 4,892
ballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond reputeballbasher101 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Nalbandian vs Davydenko: Who was the better player/whose peak level is higher/etc

I like both players. The Burger king edges it for me. At his best even Federer struggled to deal with him.
ballbasher101 is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


Copyright (C) Verticalscope Inc
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007, PixelFX Studios