Endless Federer-Nadal debates - Page 86 - MensTennisForums.com

MensTennisForums.com

MenstennisForums.com is the premier Men's Tennis forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.Please Register - It's Free!

View Poll Results: How will it look?

Nadal more than 15 matches ahead. 103 39.31%
Nadal 13-14 matches ahead. 25 9.54%
Nadal 11-12 matches ahead. 19 7.25%
Nadal 9-10 matches ahead. 20 7.63%
Nadal 7-8 matches ahead. 20 7.63%
Nadal 5-6 matches ahead. 18 6.87%
Nadal 3-4 matches ahead. 5 1.91%
Nadal 1-2 matches ahead. 1 0.38%
Equal 4 1.53%
Federer ahead 47 17.94%
Voters: 262. You may not vote on this poll

Reply

Old 11-26-2012, 09:09 PM   #1276
country flag JanKowalski
Registered User
 
JanKowalski's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Poland
Age: 32
Posts: 1,890
JanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond reputeJanKowalski has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Lenders View Post
Thanks. Always glad to lend my services as an observant and unbiased analyst of the game and its players
How cute. 2 clowns licking their asses.
JanKowalski is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 

Old 11-26-2012, 09:26 PM   #1277
country flag BauerAlmeida
Registered User
 
BauerAlmeida's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Argentina
Age: 22
Posts: 3,922
BauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Lenders View Post
Federer is the more talented tennis player, Nadal is the more talented athlete.

Basically, Federer was born to play tennis, he understands the game like no other and thus can play at maybe the highest level the sport has ever seen (during his prime) without putting much strain on his body, which is why he could conceivably remain a top 10 player until his late 30s, 40yo. Nadal, on the other hand, could probably succeed in a lot of different sports with his freakish athletic ability/talent; he's probably the most natural player ever on a claycourt, but outside of clay he has definitely benefitted from playing in an era where surfaces are slow enough to let his main attributes (speed, stamina, athleticism) shine. He most definitely can't play at a top level as 'effortlessly' as Federer, he's really putting his body on the line out there with outrageous physical feats. Tennis doesn't come as natural to him as it does to Federer.

With that said, Federer is an amazing athlete too, and Nadal has a lot of talent for tennis of course, don't let his unortodox technique fool you. The reason why both have such an amazing resumé is because they're beyong gifted in one of these aspects (Federer tennis talent, Nadal athletic ability) but also extraordinary in the other aspect, and both extremely strong mentally.
This sums it up pretty well.
BauerAlmeida is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-26-2012, 09:33 PM   #1278
country flag BauerAlmeida
Registered User
 
BauerAlmeida's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Argentina
Age: 22
Posts: 3,922
BauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by JanKowalski View Post
How cute. 2 clowns licking their asses.
At least he wrote a good post explaining his point of view (only 2 o 3 did that). What did you do?? Besides from calling the OP a clown or a troll or something like that.
BauerAlmeida is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 12:13 AM   #1279
country flag Fujee
Registered User
 
Fujee's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,330
Fujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond reputeFujee has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Lenders View Post
Federer is the more talented tennis player, Nadal is the more talented athlete.

Basically, Federer was born to play tennis, he understands the game like no other and thus can play at maybe the highest level the sport has ever seen (during his prime) without putting much strain on his body, which is why he could conceivably remain a top 10 player until his late 30s, 40yo. Nadal, on the other hand, could probably succeed in a lot of different sports with his freakish athletic ability/talent; he's probably the most natural player ever on a claycourt, but outside of clay he has definitely benefitted from playing in an era where surfaces are slow enough to let his main attributes (speed, stamina, athleticism) shine. He most definitely can't play at a top level as 'effortlessly' as Federer, he's really putting his body on the line out there with outrageous physical feats. Tennis doesn't come as natural to him as it does to Federer.

With that said, Federer is an amazing athlete too, and Nadal has a lot of talent for tennis of course, don't let his unortodox technique fool you. The reason why both have such an amazing resumé is because they're beyong gifted in one of these aspects (Federer tennis talent, Nadal athletic ability) but also extraordinary in the other aspect, and both extremely strong mentally.
Best post you've made.
__________________
Genius is not replicable. Inspiration, though, is contagious, and multiform — and even just to see, close up, power and aggression made vulnerable to beauty is to feel inspired and (in a fleeting, mortal way) reconciled.

David Foster Wallace
Fujee is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 12:44 AM   #1280
country flag Black Adam
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Nirvana
Posts: 7,183
Black Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond reputeBlack Adam has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Without Nadal and Djokovic, Federer would have made a joke of tennis.Tennis would have been murdered by Federer being too good without adequate challenge.
__________________
There an only be One Nadal
Quote:
Nadal, Roddick, Tsonga, Del Potro & Safin
Quote:
Pele was the black Rooney
Quote:
Originally Posted by George W Bush
"We must always remember that all human beings begin life as a feces. A Feces is a living being in the eyes of God, who has endowed that feces with all of the rights and God-given blessings of any other human being."
Black Adam is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 01:15 AM   #1281
country flag BauerAlmeida
Registered User
 
BauerAlmeida's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Argentina
Age: 22
Posts: 3,922
BauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond reputeBauerAlmeida has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Adam View Post
Without Nadal and Djokovic, Federer would have made a joke of tennis.Tennis would have been murdered by Federer being too good without adequate challenge.
Djokovic appeared a bit "late" in Federer's career. But if it wasn't for Nadal Federer would have been the most dominant athlete at any sport and the undisputed goat. We would be talking about a guy having 20+ slams, 2 calendar grand slams, like 4 career grand slams, 10 slams in a row and 500 weeks in a row at number 1 maybe.

Good thing that Nadal appeared. As you said, Federer would have kill tennis if not.

Any of those 3 would have dominated easily tennis without the other 2, but because of his consistency and longevity Federer would have it even easier.
BauerAlmeida is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 02:48 AM   #1282
country flag GOATsol
Registered User
 
GOATsol's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Age: 19
Posts: 2,085
GOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond reputeGOATsol has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Quote:
Originally Posted by BauerAlmeida View Post
Djokovic appeared a bit "late" in Federer's career. But if it wasn't for Nadal Federer would have been the most dominant athlete at any sport and the undisputed goat. We would be talking about a guy having 20+ slams, 2 calendar grand slams, like 4 career grand slams, 10 slams in a row and 500 weeks in a row at number 1 maybe.

Good thing that Nadal appeared. As you said, Federer would have kill tennis if not.

Any of those 3 would have dominated easily tennis without the other 2, but because of his consistency and longevity Federer would have it even easier.
I don't think he would have killed tennis--and I think Roger once said that you can't just take Nadal away and say that he would have dominated everything, because there would have been someone else.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noserer View Post
Nadal of course. He and Djokovic are by far the most likeable members in top 4.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt01 View Post
As a knowledgable tennis fan (unlike some people here), I can tell you exactly that. There are tennis players who have problems with playing indoor tennis because of the different lights, different sounds etc. compared to outdoors and Nadal is obvioulsy one of those players.
GOATsol is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 05:12 AM   #1283
country flag Litotes
ALT-0
 
Litotes's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Norway
Age: 41
Posts: 31,404
Litotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond reputeLitotes has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Quote:
Originally Posted by BauerAlmeida View Post
Djokovic appeared a bit "late" in Federer's career. But if it wasn't for Nadal Federer would have been the most dominant athlete at any sport and the undisputed goat. We would be talking about a guy having 20+ slams, 2 calendar grand slams, like 4 career grand slams, 10 slams in a row and 500 weeks in a row at number 1 maybe.

Good thing that Nadal appeared. As you said, Federer would have kill tennis if not.

Any of those 3 would have dominated easily tennis without the other 2, but because of his consistency and longevity Federer would have it even easier.
500 weeks is a bit much. We're not even at the point where it's 500 weeks since Federer's first week as #1 yet, and it's not Nadal holding him back now.

As for dominance killing, it doesn't seem to hurt in other sports. Interest in greco-roman wrestling heavyweight class was far, far, higher when Alexander Karelin was active and he won every match for 13 years straight.
Litotes is online now View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 05:36 AM   #1284
country flag finishingmove
Registered User
 
finishingmove's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Age: 26
Posts: 21,787
finishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond reputefinishingmove has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Nadal is an incredibly inspiring athlete and character, while it's a real shame that a person like Federer got so much exposure anywhere.

At least he used to play some good tennis, but now it's time for him to leave -- and it wouldn't have come a moment too soon.

There are just two bad things: Nadal's injuries and Djokovic's inexplicable slump after AO 2008. Hopefully, in good health, they will beat the old man into the ground and be done with it.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mjau! View Post
Spending time with your children and not being a wage slave at some soulless corporation or government bureaucracy sounds like hell. Haven't we progressed beyond the idea that it is in loving relationships with other people that we find fulfillment and meaning? Climbing the corporate ladder is essential in the pursuit of happiness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Oracle View Post
Match Point Novak needs to be immortalized in sculpture, like Michelangelo's David. I'm sure that once he's gone to tennis Valhalla, his statue will have his stones as the focal point of attention, and tennis fans will make a meccan-like pilgrimage at least once in their lifetime, in order to rub those lucky stones, like the budda's belly.
finishingmove is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 05:51 AM   #1285
country flag Johnbert
Registered User
 
Johnbert's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 3,977
Johnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noserer View Post
Of course he is, most players are more talented than Federer. In fact, Nadal is so talented that he's been able to win 11 slams with his weaker hand. That's something Federer can only dream of.
yeah, nadal would've won at least 25 slams if he would be a righty
Johnbert is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 05:55 AM   #1286
country flag Johnbert
Registered User
 
Johnbert's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 3,977
Johnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Quote:
Originally Posted by finishingmove View Post
Nadal is an incredibly inspiring athlete and character, while it's a real shame that a person like Federer got so much exposure anywhere.

At least he used to play some good tennis, but now it's time for him to leave -- and it wouldn't have come a moment too soon.

There are just two bad things: Nadal's injuries and Djokovic's inexplicable slump after AO 2008. Hopefully, in good health, they will beat the old man into the ground and be done with it.
so much bitterness
Johnbert is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 05:59 AM   #1287
country flag Johnbert
Registered User
 
Johnbert's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 3,977
Johnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond reputeJohnbert has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Is Nadal more talented than Federer?

Quote:
Originally Posted by GSMnadal View Post
I don't care if he's more talented or not, he's the better player and that's what counts.
tennis isn't only played on clay
Johnbert is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 10:09 AM   #1288
country flag Sophocles
Registered User
 
Sophocles's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Age: 40
Posts: 8,933
Sophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond reputeSophocles has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Some of the answers here - including from posters I have a lot of time for - are out of Alice Through the Looking Glass. What is this distinction between technique & athleticism anyway? Er yeah Nadal runs a bit faster than Fed. And he's better at moonballing, sorry, topspin. And er, that's it. In every other respect - hand-eye co-ordination, touch, imagination & vision, technique, reflexes, suppleness, variety - Federer is superior to Nadal.
__________________
"There is no such thing as 'the world'." - Enoch Powell.
Sophocles is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 10:40 AM   #1289
country flag duong
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 11,346
duong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond reputeduong has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sophocles View Post
What is this distinction between technique & athleticism anyway?
and what is this distinction between "tennis abilities" and "athlectic abilities" which I've so much read ?

Athleticism is a big big part of tennis nowadays, tennis is not in Nastase's time anymore (I'm also sorry about that like you ), it's a very physical sport

Besides, Nadal has other abilities than the ones you mentioned.
__________________
useless old guy
duong is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Old 11-27-2012, 10:41 AM   #1290
country flag JurajCrane
Registered User
 
JurajCrane's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 1,364
JurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond reputeJurajCrane has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Endless Federer-Nadal debates (Did their rivalry strangle the game?

^ Sophocles summed it nicely, maybe even Nadulltards will understand ... But we never know about them
__________________
Roger Federer - Martin Klizan - Lukas Lacko - Grigor Dimitrov - Fernando Verdasco

Dustin Brown - Nick Kyrgios - Norbert Gombos - Stanislas Wawrinka - Dominic Thiem
JurajCrane is online now View My Blog!   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


Copyright (C) Verticalscope Inc
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007, PixelFX Studios