[ezekiel]

Originally Posted by bad gambler

So why are you posting in this thread?

if I or most posters here don't know him how can he deserve a forum ? :retard: Not that I know everything but still
Ok, I looked him up and he is a young challenger player ranked 173, nothing exciting yet to warrant a forum on his own. How low can you go to warrant a forum ? Mind you there are already many forums that are not active at all and should be closed or archived but I am not a mod and if guys like Karol Beck, Ilia Bozoljac, Taylor Dent have it then who am I to argue ?

[RickDaStick]

Originally Posted by ezekiel

if I or most posters here don't know him how can he deserve a forum ? :retard: Not that I know everything but still
Ok, I looked him up and he is a young challenger player ranked 173, nothing exciting yet to warrant a forum on his own. How low can you go to warrant a forum ? Mind you there are already many forums that are not active at all and should be closed or archived but I am not a mod and if guys like Karol Beck, Ilia Bozoljac, Taylor Dent have it then who am I to argue ?

I doubt most posters dont know who he is. Not everyone is just a fan of federers like yourself.

Originally Posted by ezekiel

if I or most posters here don't know him how can he deserve a forum ? :retard: Not that I know everything but still

I didn't realise that a criteria for creating a new player forum was that you in particular had to know who the player was

Originally Posted by ezekiel

Ok, I looked him up and he is a young challenger player ranked 173, nothing exciting yet to warrant a forum on his own. How low can you go to warrant a forum ?

I didn't realise another criteria was that the player had to be a top 10 to get a forum either

Originally Posted by ezekiel

Mind you there are already many forums that are not active at all and should be closed or archived but I am not a mod and if guys like Karol Beck, Ilia Bozoljac, Taylor Dent have it then who am I to argue ?

Yep it is not your decision

I'll ask Steve about this suggestion and the Italian forum request

[savesthedizzle]

I actually think most users on MTF do know who Cilic is, ezekiel. He's discussed pretty often as an up and comer.

[meninosantos]

Originally Posted by ezekiel

if I or most posters here don't know him how can he deserve a forum ? :retard: Not that I know everything but still
Ok, I looked him up and he is a young challenger player ranked 173, nothing exciting yet to warrant a forum on his own. How low can you go to warrant a forum ? Mind you there are already many forums that are not active at all and should be closed or archived but I am not a mod and if guys like Karol Beck, Ilia Bozoljac, Taylor Dent have it then who am I to argue ?

Cilic was juniors world number 1...And his carreer is growing...

[Deboogle!.]

Originally Posted by bad gambler

I'll ask Steve about this suggestion and the Italian forum request

Other player forum suggestions have been around much longer and have just as much support. Either all of them should be addressed or Steve should put up the poll suggestions, and then the poll, like he said was going to happen?

Originally Posted by Deb!.

Other player forum suggestions have been around much longer and have just as much support. Either all of them should be addressed or Steve should put up the poll suggestions, and then the poll, like he said was going to happen?

What I meant was I was going to ask Steve to readdress the creation of player forums rules he has in place in terms of frequency

So Rochus and Calleri fans can allay their fears that their requests will not be missed

[Deboogle!.]

gotcha (we Querrey fans are also getting restless and hadn't started a thread because of the whole thing )

[ezekiel]

Originally Posted by savestheday91

I actually think most users on MTF do know who Cilic is, ezekiel. He's discussed pretty often as an up and comer.

Ok but he is now mainly a challenger type player but hey if people want it , more power to them

[ezekiel]

Originally Posted by Ruisantos

Cilic was juniors world number 1...And his carreer is growing...

I didn't know he was #1 which explains that he has good talent so I understand the hype

[savesthedizzle]

Originally Posted by ezekiel

Ok but he is now mainly a challenger type player but hey if people want it , more power to them

When we got Novak's forum he had just barely cracked the top 100 He was only ranked around 86. But we knew his potential

They know his And I think if they want a forum and if they would make good use of a forum, then why shouldn't they have one?

[ezekiel]

Originally Posted by savestheday91

When we got Novak's forum he had just barely cracked the top 100 He was only ranked around 86. But we knew his potential

They know his And I think if they want a forum and if they would make good use of a forum, then why shouldn't they have one?

Nole started a forum after USO 2005 , right ?

[gusman890]

Ive noticed Cilic during the 2005 orange bowl with his race with Donald Young to see who would be the no.1 junior for the year.

and hes been raising up the rankings fairly good i must say since then. Even played DC dispite getting slautered by Fat Dave

[El Legenda]

Cilic forum Yes!