MensTennisForums.com - View Single Post - Week 11 : Dallas-2 (Winner : Jurgen Melzer)

View Single Post

Old 03-14-2013, 02:37 AM   #61
country flag dencod16
Registered User
 
dencod16's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 5,443
dencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond reputedencod16 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Week 11 : Dallas-2 (Entry List)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Beta2k View Post
so why did petzschner need a WC and bachinger not? does someone know the rulebook to confirm the fact that the alternate list is based on the ranking of the day when the draw is made? because in that ranking bachinger would be in front of petzsche..
I think the loophole is in this rule

If a withdrawal occurs after 12 noon, Eastern Time, USA, on Friday, the vacancy will be filled by
the highest ranked player from that event’s qualifying sign-in list and players from
the original alternate list who have contacted the on-site Supervisor prior to the
qualifying sign-in deadline and preserved their eligibility on the new alternate list.
A player can only preserve his eligibility on one list.

That is the only thing that actually makes sense, with Sela not getting in. Sela was also ranked higher than Petzschner and Bachinger but didn't get in.

Also based on the draw http://www.atpworldtour.com/posting/2013/6486/mds.pdf as you can see Bachinger last acceptance with 109 and this is ranking history

04.03.2013 109
25.02.2013 111
18.02.2013 112
11.02.2013 125
04.02.2013 124
28.01.2013 124
14.01.2013 124
07.01.2013 125

so clearly the acceptance list was altered and was based on the most recent rankings

10 Russell, Michael USA 70
Brands, Daniel GER 74
Roger-Vasselin, Edouard FRA 78
Berankis, Ricardas LTU 80
11. Ito, Tatsuma JPN 84
Garcia-Lopez, Guillermo ESP 86
12. Kamke, Tobias GER 87
13 Rufin, Guillaume FRA 89
14. Pella, Guido ARG 103
15. Hajek, Jan CZE 96
Levine, Jesse CAN 97
16. Smyczek, Tim USA 104
17. Darcis, Steve BEL 105
18. Cipolla, Flavio ITA 107
19. Stakhovsky, Sergiy UKR 108
20. Bachinger, Matthias GER 109
Ungur, Adrian ROU 110
WC. Petzschner, Philipp GER 119
Sela, Dudi ISR 122

and the top 4 Baghdatis, Bellucci, Troicki and Melzer were placed on top of the alternate list.
dencod16 is offline View My Blog!   Reply With Quote