Originally Posted by Lestat
Nole won Wimbledon in his magic year, he won there because his level was insane, not because he is great on grass,
When you're a great player you will play great in your weakest surface too. Federer is not a great claycourter, but he was constantly reaching Roland Garros finals because his level in the surface was good enough to beat everyone bar Nadal.
Roddick and Murray may be have a style that suits grass better but it wasn't enough for them to win Wimbledon.