Originally Posted by duarte_a
Also Roger made the finals of MC, ROme and RG in 2006, MC and RG in 2007, MC and RG in 2008, Madrid in 2009, Madrid in 2010, RG in 2011. He could very well have "dodged" some of these matches.
He probably should've since had Federer been less formidable/consistent on clay, it would have made the H-H argument moot along with the psychological baggage Federer had to endure on account of all those defeats. Apparently for some Nadal tards (or anti-Fed tards for that matter), the lack of a skewed H-H would have also given Federer's status as GOAT more legitimacy.