MensTennisForums.com - Reply to Topic

Thread: Suicide Tennis - Miami Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the MensTennisForums.com forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.



  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
03-30-2014 09:46 PM
Fargif
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pratik View Post
So, I think your opinion reduces to letting W/O's being counted as a win. The problem with that was discussed recently(can't remember where). The points brought up against that did convince me. What if someone gives a walkover before the first ball is played? Then participants can pick that player for a sure advancement to the next day. Situations like this tournament are extremely rare. Adding a provision for this won't make any difference.
We talked about time management some might get info faster or ealier then others, in this case if you changed your pick and i didnt its on me.

This time was a double WO it will happen again probably not soon.

In another scenario you pick has 1st serve. The other player falls and breaks a leg, he cant play, your guy moves on but you loose your pick. Your Back up pick Advances to next round due walover also and your tournament is done. And both your picks are still valid for thoer guys in the next round.
03-30-2014 09:31 PM
Pratik
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fargif View Post
Of course it does. We make our picks based on strat, luck , draws etc. To fit in mugs who widrew from certain matches. There are those who use and abuse it. Davydenko comes to mind.

And because in wasnt in the end this time doesnt mean i still dont feel same way.

Those who picked either Rafa or Nole should get one more pick if avaible. To me doesnt make sense lossing while the players they picked went to the final.

Sorry, im not smarter then any of you. I just dont see the logic.
So, I think your opinion reduces to letting W/O's being counted as a win. The problem with that was discussed recently(can't remember where). The points brought up against that did convince me. What if someone gives a walkover before the first ball is played? Then participants can pick that player for a sure advancement to the next day. Situations like this tournament are extremely rare. Adding a provision for this won't make any difference.
03-30-2014 09:21 PM
Fargif
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pratik View Post
Every game has some aspect of luck in it.
Of course it does. We make our picks based on strat, luck , draws etc. To fit in mugs who widrew from certain matches. There are those who use and abuse it. Davydenko comes to mind.

And because in wasnt in the end this time doesnt mean i still dont feel same way.

Those who picked either Rafa or Nole should get one more pick if avaible. To me doesnt make sense lossing while the players they picked went to the final.

Sorry, im not smarter then any of you. I just dont see the logic.
03-30-2014 09:18 PM
Fargif
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

3rd pick will not prevent this from happening.
03-30-2014 09:17 PM
Pratik
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fargif View Post
Remember me? I said a few weeks ago same thing nobody listened. I even asked about a sceneraio where both picks got WO.

Again my problem with this is just one thing. If i picked Kei and or Berdych and we know what happened i wouldnt have a problem with loosing the game.

But for those who picked Rafa and Nole its unfair becuase those 2 will advance to next round.

I have been thinking about ways to get around this and adding a 3rd pick would be the easy way out but it could still happen.

This week in sf we dont have room to change. But in early rounds there is always.

Its not my fault the player i picked got a ticket to next round because the other guy pulled out.
Every game has some aspect of luck in it.
03-30-2014 09:14 PM
Litotes
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fargif View Post
Remember me? I said a few weeks ago same thing nobody listened. I even asked about a sceneraio where both picks got WO.

Again my problem with this is just one thing. If i picked Kei and or Berdych and we know what happened i wouldnt have a problem with loosing the game.

But for those who picked Rafa and Nole its unfair becuase those 2 will advance to next round.

I have been thinking about ways to get around this and adding a 3rd pick would be the easy way out but it could still happen.

This week in sf we dont have room to change. But in early rounds there is always.

Its not my fault the player i picked got a ticket to next round because the other guy pulled out.
I remember you, yes, I feel you got a thorough explanation about how the rules work. Now you got to see it's not just you being unlucky this way.

Adding a 3rd pick shouldn't be a problem. If you want to do that go right ahead.
03-30-2014 09:08 PM
Fargif
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Litotes View Post
We could consider this new rule but it's not like this sort of thing happens often so it would be very little demand for it.

In other events there are more leeway for the unexpected. IW and Miami are unusual in that you have to accurately predict all four QFs. If they had been played on the same day, which is more common, you can skip one altogether, just having to guess correctly one winner who will lose in the SF and ofc the two finalists to win.

Remember me? I said a few weeks ago same thing nobody listened. I even asked about a sceneraio where both picks got WO.

Again my problem with this is just one thing. If i picked Kei and or Berdych and we know what happened i wouldnt have a problem with loosing the game.

But for those who picked Rafa and Nole its unfair becuase those 2 will advance to next round.

I have been thinking about ways to get around this and adding a 3rd pick would be the easy way out but it could still happen.

This week in sf we dont have room to change. But in early rounds there is always.

Its not my fault the player i picked got a ticket to next round because the other guy pulled out.
03-30-2014 06:33 PM
Litotes
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Lenders View Post
I imagine it's very difficult to actually win a title. I've only played this game twice now, but I tend to make predictions for tournaments as they go along anyway, and only very, very rarely does every result goes the way I expect from R16 on - in the past year, that has only happened in Shanghai 2013 as far as big events are concerned. There's almost always at least one result I really can't see coming, which in a game like this is enough to end title aspirations.

As for this very bizarre situation in the SFs, perhaps a rule whereby a player progresses if both his first pick and backup don't get to play due to withdraws? It's pretty unlucky for a player to lose in a situation where both his pick and backup don't take to the court, I mean for all intents and purposes his picks didn't really lose.
We could consider this new rule but it's not like this sort of thing happens often so it would be very little demand for it.

In other events there are more leeway for the unexpected. IW and Miami are unusual in that you have to accurately predict all four QFs. If they had been played on the same day, which is more common, you can skip one altogether, just having to guess correctly one winner who will lose in the SF and ofc the two finalists to win.
03-30-2014 06:25 PM
Mark Lenders
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Litotes View Post
I think most of us had planned that one, I know I had Though surely Federer-Berdych-Djokovic-Nadal would also have produced some winners. But, as usual - barring another Nishikori surprise - it was not to be. This game is indeed difficult. Myself, I haven't won a title yet. Closest was Shanghai 2012 when I had Murray in the final.......
I imagine it's very difficult to actually win a title. I've only played this game twice now, but I tend to make predictions for tournaments as they go along anyway, and only very, very rarely does every result goes the way I expect from R16 on - in the past year, that has only happened in Shanghai 2013 as far as big events are concerned. There's almost always at least one result I really can't see coming, which in a game like this is enough to end title aspirations.

As for this very bizarre situation in the SFs, perhaps a rule whereby a player progresses if both his first pick and backup don't get to play due to withdraws? It's pretty unlucky for a player to lose in a situation where both his pick and backup don't take to the court, I mean for all intents and purposes his picks didn't really lose.
03-29-2014 09:31 AM
Litotes
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pratik View Post
In accordance to the actual tournament, the four players should also have been given a W/O to today.
That would have been something

In case anyone wants to ask for a rule change where you can proceed of a WO if all matches in a round ends in WO, then I can tell you this has been suggested before and was in the end voted down.
03-29-2014 09:06 AM
Pratik
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

In accordance to the actual tournament, the four players should also have been given a W/O to today.
03-29-2014 06:16 AM
Litotes
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bazza View Post
so, there was no way to win this tournament, right?
That's right. A tournament with all WOs in one particular round cannot be won under the rules.
03-29-2014 03:11 AM
Bazza
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

so, there was no way to win this tournament, right?
03-28-2014 11:24 PM
Litotes
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

What an awful finish! Still, I'd like to congratulate those making it until today. A double WO in the SFs, can't remember ever seeing anything like it....
03-28-2014 10:24 PM
bry17may
Re: Suicide Tennis - Miami

Quote:
Originally Posted by RNW View Post
What are the rules with no match being played?
All are eliminated
This thread has more than 15 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome