<<<RATE ANDY RODDICK's SKILLS>>> [Archive] - MensTennisForums.com

<<<RATE ANDY RODDICK's SKILLS>>>

RealityRyan
01-16-2004, 03:39 PM
I made this up for FEDEX but hey, why let it go to waste. Rate Andy's skills as compared to everyone else in the game. Here are my ratings.

RealityRyan's player breakdown for Andy

(stars are out of 6)

Andy Roddick:

Forehand:* * * * *
I give Andy five stars on his forehand. He has the ability to end a point from anywhere on the court with it. The pace, and placement on his forehand is currently unmatched....

Backand:* * *
A definite weak point for Roddick but, he has learned to work around it and make it more consistent. Generally he will run around it if given the chance.

Serve:* * * * * *
The fastest serve in Tennis...when Roddick is hot...he won't be broken...nuff said..

Movement and Mobility:* * *
Well he's no Michael Chang but he moves pretty quickly when has too.

Focus/Mental Ability:* * * *
Certainly lacking in the Early part of Roddick's Career but, now he is able finish and make comebacks from behind without nerves getting to him.

Net Skills:* *
Not very Sampras like...but he can rush the net when he has too and has been able to mix it up as of recent times.

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 03:46 PM
Erm......ok!

Forehand: ****
4 instead of 5 only because the sloppy wristy-ness. I hope he doesn't get a chronic injury b/c of it. Otherwise his forehand is incredible (see: Match point against him last year's AO QF)

Backhand: ***
What you said.... and it's improving

Serve: *****
Because there's always room for improvement ;)

Movement: **
I think this is where he has the most to work on. If he had to be so scrappy when he was little, I don't know why he's so choppy now but it sounds like he knows this is really important to improve, so that is a good sign.

Focus/Mental: *** (it was about ***** last summer and I'd like to see it get back there)
He's getting better but as we saw last night, he's still spotty and still gets line calls and stuff get to him too much.

Net Skills: **3/4
He's getting so much better, and I love that he's now comfortable enough serve-volleying as a risk when he's down break point, to me that shows massive improvement.

And you forgot one...

Return: **
As he said as of late, he knows this is huge. His returning is pretty poor now. he pops a lot of returns on easy second-serves out and if he could get on the ball and be agressive and get stuff like that in, he'd break a lot more. And since he's hard to break, if he can play better return games he'll be lethal.

RealityRyan
01-16-2004, 03:57 PM
yes.. I did forget Return

Return: * * *
Not as bad as some think but not that good. He needs to work on moving up closer to the baseline. Hitting shots from like 10 miles behind the baseline really limits your options and is a great way of taking your self out of a point. Still he comes through with a big return(s) when he has to. Watch the Lbjucic match from US open last year.

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 04:08 PM
yea.... that sounded like a quick fix from everything everyone said. It won't work on the longterm so I hope they've worked on it. Guess we'll see in a couple days where he stands. Haven't gotten any word about that in particular from Kooyong or anything.

Havok
01-16-2004, 04:32 PM
serve:*****
it can improve, but face it, its the best serve out there, so it deserves a 5 on 5.

forehand:****1/2
he can still learn how to hit them better, hit them flatter, etc.

backhand:***
it turned into a very steady shot that really holds up during his backhand passing shots. needs to add more sting to it

movement:***1/2
for a guy that big and weighing that heavy, he's a very good mover, but he can improve on it

focus:***3/4
like bunk said, summer hardcourts 2003 was more of a 4-5, but it's dipped. the fact that he always fights out there and never gives up is a positive

net skills:***
used to be like a 1, big max 2. he can now hit very nice volleys(see def Malisse 4th round US Open 2003) can still get better, but his volleys are better than quite a few players

return:***
he has to learn how to return on the baseline more, but it will take him some time. he's now able to really crunch at least 1 return every match i've seen so far with Gilbert as his coach, so its getting better

RealityRyan
01-16-2004, 05:36 PM
that's cool everyone else's opinions are pretty close to my own..

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 05:44 PM
lol naldo 3 and a quarter on the return ;) What gives the extra 1/4 if I may ask?

star
01-16-2004, 05:52 PM
Well, I was wondering the same about you, Bunk. What gave Andy 1/4 less than 4 on the netgame. ;)

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 05:54 PM
because he's not good enough for 4 stars yet but I think he's better than 3.... maybe 3 1/2 was more appropriate :p

RealityRyan
01-16-2004, 06:05 PM
Andy's net game is well, not to good. I think anything over 2 stars starts to make it average or maybe a little bit of a strength and it's not. It's a weak point. So two stars...

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 06:52 PM
He's gotten a lot better. The fact that he will S-V down break point shows me that he's a lot more confident in his volleying than he used to be. And confidence seems to breed success for him.... so yeah. it's not as much a liability as it was.

Havok
01-16-2004, 07:10 PM
lol naldo 3 and a quarter on the return ;) What gives the extra 1/4 if I may ask?
actually my bad, gave him to high of a rating. changed it from 3 1/4 to a solid 3. his return game is just about average, if he steps closer a few more times, then he'll get another 1/2 stars. this will always be andy's weakness, but because he has a 5 serve, it puts pressure on his opponents when serving, so they can serve stupidly and Andy can take advantage of it

heya
01-16-2004, 10:56 PM
...hasn't really taken advantage of the off-season to train.
Forehand: ****

Backhand: ** passive

Serve: **** needs good placement,
ineffective when he's exhausted, double faults more 'cuz he's not
slowing it down, flattening out the trajectory,
has to take time before serve,

Movement: ** bad court positioning, little improvement, poor footwork-not working hard

Focus: *1/2
constantly shows embarrassment-either too little or too much aggression vs. tougher opponents,

opponent didn't hit a great shot,
he made an unforced error, but he acted like his opponent did somethiing amazing,

premature celebrations/applauds opponents
(self-humiliation's tiring), loses concentration,

has no strategy when he's in a slump, unprepared

stop denying that he's struggling

Net Skills: * No practice...nice

Return: **

Training: *

star
01-16-2004, 11:00 PM
:lol:

Heya worships Andy more than anyone and is harder on him than anyone.

:bigclap:

Deboogle!.
01-16-2004, 11:27 PM
I guess!!!!!!!!!!!! He trained incredibly hard over the off-season have ya SEEN THE MUSCLES?????

star
01-16-2004, 11:49 PM
I didn't see a six pack.

I don't really remember how he looked before. He didn't blow me away with his physical condition.

J. Corwin
01-17-2004, 01:26 AM
Out of 6 stars:

Forehand: ****
--Nice power, but still not consistent enough sometimes. He needs to learn to control it more and be able to hit with more angles.

Backhand: **1/2
--He has hit some great down-the-line backhands, but those usually come few and far between. He very often just hits it back tamely cross court. He isn't aggressive enough with this shot. He should surprise opponents more with power dtl backhands, and make sure it lands in of course.

Serve: *****1/2
--With the exception of occasional blips, he holds his serve. This shot has saved him many times in matches. He has great pace and a great kick 2nd serve. He could still improve on moving it around the box and add variety (ie. slice serve in ad court).

Return: **
--By far the weakest part of his game (his backhand comes in a very close second). He has hit some great return winners (Cincy '03 SF v. Miryni). He has also sprayed his returns or they land very short (Cincy '03 F v. Fish). Standing so far behind the baseline to return serve makes him look very inefficient.

Movement/Mobility: ***
--He can move fairly well but at times he still looks clumsy on court. He has to cover so much ground because he can be so far behind the baseline. This also makes him very susceptible to drop shots.

Focus/Mental: ***
--He is a fighter and never tanks matches. His strong will to win has gotten him far and he has had some remarkable comebacks in his career. His recent inability to win tiebreaks keeps him from getting 4, or even 5, stars. His summer run last year would be a 5. He used to be so comfortable and confident in TBs. Hopefully this doesn't develop into a mental block in which he doesn't believe he can win them anymore.

Net Skills: ***
--Enough to usually get the job done, backed behind a power serve or approach shot. He has improved on this a lot since a year or two ago.


Overall: 3.2857 stars :p
(I took the average of the categories. ;) )

RealityRyan
01-17-2004, 08:07 PM
I didn't see a six pack.

I don't really remember how he looked before. He didn't blow me away with his physical condition.
http://www.australianopen.com/images/pics/large/b_roddick_1601.jpg

Deboogle!.
01-17-2004, 08:43 PM
he is a lot bigger than before..... I noticed especially after watching him in the TMC documentary compared with these newer pics from Melbourne.

SaFed2005
01-25-2004, 05:01 PM
Out of 10

Forehand:9
Backand:5
Serve:9.5
Movement and Mobility:7
Focus/Mental Ability:8
Net Skills: 5

tangerine_dream
01-25-2004, 05:05 PM
Welcome anantak2K :wavey:

J. Corwin
01-25-2004, 06:50 PM
Howdy Anantak2k :D

Havok
01-25-2004, 06:54 PM
Anantak2k:wavey: