Grand Slam midgets? [Archive] - MensTennisForums.com

Grand Slam midgets?

shotgun
06-01-2008, 12:13 AM
By GS midgets I mean players that had a pretty good ranking but always failed to deliver in the big four.

I think a good criteria would be players that reached the top 20 at some point but never got past the third round of any Slam, or players that reached the top 10 but never got past the fourth round.

Agustin Calleri is one that springs to mind:

Career High ATP Ranking - Singles: 16 (7-Jul-03)
Best Slam performance: 3rd Round (Roland Garros '00, US Open '00, '07)

Nicolas Massu:
Career High ATP Ranking - Singles: 9 (13-Sep-04)
Best Slam performance: 4th Round (US Open '05)

Any other players?

shotgun
06-01-2008, 12:34 AM
Paradorn Srichaphan:

Career High ATP Ranking - Singles: 9 (12-May-03)
Best Slam performance: R16 (Australian Open'04, Wimbledon '03, Us Open' 03)


Albert Portas:

Career High ATP Ranking - Singles: 19 (1-Oct-01)
Best Slam performance: R32 (Roland Garros '97, '00, '02, Wimbledon '00, US Open '01)

Could also fit the criteria former top 30 players that never got to the third round, and top 40 players that never won a Slam match (doubt that anyone would show up :lol:).

TankingTheSet
06-01-2008, 01:20 AM
I think Fabrice Santoro qualifies although not according to your definition, his best ever ranking was 19th and he has spent almost 20 years in the top-100 and entered a record number of Grand Slam tournaments, yet his Grand Slam results were limited. Of course he made the QF in Australia in 2006 plus two fourth rounds at Roland Garros in 1991 and 2001. He must be close to being the record holder for the most first-round defeats in Grand Slams.

Neely
06-01-2008, 01:51 AM
these should be other candidates according to your definition:

Juan Aguilera
Kent Carlsson
David Pate
Gilbert Schaller
Horst Skoff
Pavel Slozil
Thierry Tulasne

Sjengster
06-01-2008, 02:57 AM
Is that Arthur Ashe and Stan Smith, Wimbledon and US Open champions, that I see on that list?

leng jai
06-01-2008, 05:17 AM
Ljuba Truba.

Neely
06-01-2008, 12:19 PM
Is that Arthur Ashe and Stan Smith, Wimbledon and US Open champions, that I see on that list?
Yes, those were two more errors. Should have noticed the error with Arthur Ashe at least.



edit #2: I found the logical error I made yesterday, the above updated list should be more accurate now.

Ivanatis
06-01-2008, 02:30 PM
Ljubicic made the semis in RG once.

I'd rather go with Karlovic, who reached only one R16 at GS-level so far.

shotgun
06-01-2008, 03:47 PM
Thanks, Neely. :hatoff:

Renaud
06-01-2008, 07:48 PM
Could also fit the criteria former top 30 players that never got to the third round, and top 40 players that never won a Slam match (doubt that anyone would show up :lol:).

Juan Antonio Marin was only 55th at his best but somehow deserves to be called a GS midget.
He has lost his all 17 GS first round.
The closest he was to win was when he lost against Sampras in RG 99 ( 7-6(5) 4-6 5-7 7-6(9) 4-6)

Neely
06-01-2008, 09:45 PM
Players ranked between #21 and #30 but never made the third round:

Claudio Mezzadri
Harel Levy
Julian Alonso
Paolo Cane

jayjay
06-04-2008, 05:25 PM
By GS midgets I mean players that had a pretty good ranking but always failed to deliver in the big four.

I think a good criteria would be players that reached the top 20 at some point but never got past the third round of any Slam, or players that reached the top 10 but never got past the fourth round.
Any other players?

Ivo Karlovic.

Career high 18.

20 slams played. Been past the 3rd round once (4th round Wimbledon 2004).

The best of his stats is that of the 20 slams played, 1st round KO - 12 times.

Ouragan
07-27-2008, 05:54 PM
Paul-Henri Mathieu, 4 tournaments won but never into the 1/4s at a slam :(

shotgun
07-27-2008, 08:07 PM
Ivo Karlovic.

Career high 18.

20 slams played. Been past the 3rd round once (4th round Wimbledon 2004).

The best of his stats is that of the 20 slams played, 1st round KO - 12 times.

Karlovic is generally a midget in best-of-five matches. He is not able to keep serving rockets for more than a couple of hours, he gets tired easily. His Davis Cup record is also poor.

NoFroz
07-28-2008, 04:28 AM
Karlovic a midget, thats weird :lol:

Julian Alonso #30, best result 2 2r :help:

Renaud
07-29-2008, 09:50 AM
Simon is a top 15 now and has never been further than 3rd round in GS.

Henry Chinaski
08-08-2008, 05:03 AM
Soderling has never been past the third round and has a career high of 23.

Levels of expectation and the manner of some of his defeats in slams say more than the hard statistics though and make him a true Grand Slam Gimp.