Conclusion: Gasquet is the best among them, long life the hype
Loremaster
04-18-2007, 11:46 AM
Oh God it wasn't made to praise Gasquet I just only picked players according to results and their games Gasquet won both clay and grass tournaments made finals of TMS on clay and fast hardcourt on the other hand Berdych didn't make huge impact on hardcourts but his game really suits it
And anyway I consider Nadal much better than Gasqeut right now as well as Djokovic and Murray I think that ranking shows great postion of young players right now Nadal - Djokovic - Murray - Gasquet - Berdych
Deivid23
04-18-2007, 11:53 AM
Oh God it wasn't made to praise Gasquet I just only picked players according to results and their games Gasquet won both clay and grass tournaments made finals of TMS on clay and fast hardcourt on the other hand Berdych didn't make huge impact on hardcourts but his game really suits it
And anyway I consider Nadal much better than Gasqeut right now as well as Djokovic and Murray I think that ranking shows great postion of young players right now Nadal - Djokovic - Murray - Gasquet - Berdych
Nadal has won AMS in fast hard courts, indoors and slow hard courts has a final in Wimbledon yet Gasquet is higher in your ranking. Good call
Loremaster
04-18-2007, 11:56 AM
Come On I am bigger fan of Rafa than Richie, but Rafa is not really good on grass look at his draw at Wimbledon and during that TMS in Canada
I forgot about Nadal quite nice game indoors so I changed it a little bit
Dougie
04-18-2007, 12:01 PM
Come On I am bigger fan of Rafa than Richie, but Rafa is not really good on grass look at his draw at Wimbledon and during that TMS in Canada
I forgot about Nadal quite nice game indoors so I changed it a little bit
If someone can make it to the final of Wimbledon, it´s pretty safe to say he is really good on grass, no matter what the draw. There are not enough grass tournaments in the calendar to prove otherwise.
Deivid23
04-18-2007, 12:03 PM
Come On I am bigger fan of Rafa than Richie, but Rafa is not really good on grass look at his draw at Wimbledon and during that TMS in Canada
I forgot about Nadal quite nice game indoors so I changed it a little bit
So winning mm tourneys beating in the finals the likes of Mirnyi and Bjorkman on grass, LaLo (on clay :lol:) , and Gicquel is sth remarkable and a TMS or a Slam final is not bc of a weak field. Try harder, I hope you can do better than this
JBdV
04-18-2007, 12:07 PM
Slow hardcourts : Nadal
Clay : Nadal
Grass : Nadal
Fast Hardcourts : Nadal
Indoors : Nadal
So winning mm tourneys beating in the finals the likes of Mirnyi and Bjorkman on grass, LaLo (on clay :lol:) , and Gicquel is sth remarkable and a TMS or a Slam final is not bc of a weak field. Try harder, I hope you can do better than this
Yeah sure , still Gasquet draw at TMS Toronto up to final was much harder than rafa draw there year ago
Andre♥
04-18-2007, 12:21 PM
Slow hardcourts : Nadal, Djokovic, Murray
Clay : Nadal, Djokovic, Berdych
Grass : Djokovic, Nadal, Berdych
Fast Hardcourts : Djokovic, Berdych, Nadal
Indoors : Berdych, Djokovic, Nadal
Rafa = Fed Killa
04-18-2007, 12:38 PM
Slow hardcourts : Nadal
Clay : Nadal
Grass : Nadal
Fast Hardcourts : Nadal
Indoors : Nadal
yomike
04-18-2007, 12:41 PM
Nadal is good on all surfaces but he doesnt come off as a natural all-surface player. Watching him moonballing at Wimby was :o tragic. Murray is a claycourt hack. Djokovic seems to be good in all surface. Gasquet is a natural surface player like Nalbandian(yes hater he really is). Berdych is also good in every surface. I always thought Baghdatis was an all surface player but then he loses to Roddick and Mirnyi on clay.