Fran, on peut discuter, non ? Ne le prends pas comme ça :-( si ce thread te paraissait inintéressant, il ne fallait pas y poster, mais ne te moque pas des gens qui l'apprécient et ont aimé le livre...
I actually really dislike welovetennis habit to refer to them as the 4 fantastics... The film was pathetic and I never heard of the comics. They're trying to look cool and young but it doesn't work, it's very caricatural, ininteresting, sometimes mean and as always, they reinterpret the facts so they can fit what they want to write. Let's go with the Beatles or something then
Puschkin, I know Richie is not Gascon, I was myself in Béziers (and Sérignan !) just yesterday. But according to wikipedia
, Gascogne is a lot closer to Béziers than Paris
I only wanted to point out that both Richie and D'Artagnan entered Paris as "foreigners", from the far countryside. Whereas the other 3 have long been used to the life in the capital or in a big city (if you ever went to Sérignan you would know what I mean
I actually think Richie's accent got a looot better since those videos where he was 10 or 14 ! (me demande si les autres l'ont mis en boîte à cause de ça tiens.)
"Gloating is certainly not Richard's cup of tea"
You have to totally agree with that. Then Aramis would be my next choice for Richie, so Xrh, we have a problem
From what I recall (long time since I read the books, and no I didn't know there was a third one ! What is it about ?), Aramis is the sweetest, kindest and most sensitive one, with his dark sides since he spends half the books dealing with his own demons. He even writes poems, right
So with that insight, Aramis could be Richie or Gaël ! But Monseigneur Gillou is too perfect, I can't let it go
I still think Athos is the most fitting one for Jo
he's the perfect leader.