Oh, I agree. Some won't respect those rules anyway but in those roasting/peeling/haha thread days, you could at least have a reasonable looking match thread. You always had the haters, the gloaters but the biggest :nonsense: was for those threads and most did
Maybe it's too late to go back, though. That "one thread to bash" system worked back then and now that so many are used to just spreading it to just about every thread, they won't go back to the old system.
Take the Djokovic def. Ferrer thread. It got snowed under with the same tedious Fedtards vs Rafatards arguments. I reported it, nothing happened.