It's in the chat thread section, how is it not a chat thread?
Besides the rep itself, people leave comments. Some would like to respond to those comments or to the comment in the rep itself. What exactly is the problem or against the rules as long as it's about the said bad reps, which is the topic of the thread?
This thread is like the Goodrep thread... people don't discuss in there either. Same as: which song are you listening to, person above you, last thing you ate.... and some other threads.... intention of those threads is to post what you're listening to, who good/bad repped you etc etc. They are not "chat" chat threads. If we all start chatting in here the purpose of the thread will be lost. (if there is a purpose
Then there's the fact that THIS one will turn into a poster bashing thread (as we've seen happen many many times).
So just post who and what if you want. It's really not that difficult.