As do you
You see "arbitrary decision making" where I see mods looking at the rules, looking at the situation and applying best judgement.
You have repeatedly stated that your style of moderation is to respond to reported posts. If you are not proactive but reactive about moderating in GM, then I am sorry but that becomes "arbitrary decision making" whether you intend it or not.
For example, I find nothing wrong with any of the threads in GM by themselves. So I will not report anything. Some sensitive soul on the other hand sees the F word being used in one of the threads and reports it. You will take action on the reported thread and will leave alone a host of other similar threads because they are not reported. In this way you are catering to the whims of those few sensitive souls.
And if you ask us to report more, you are asking us to self-moderate in which case you role essentially is to use a button for deletion of posts which is completely superfluous and unnecessary.
So I am not being deluded when I say arbitrary decision making.
Secondly if you are too busy( and this I mean all the mods) to check all the threads then I really think you should give it to someone else who has the time. Here you are saying you want to ensure a degree of respectability to GM and you do not want to spend adequate time and effort on the issue.