First I have to say, love love love your new avatar Kid
Ok, so you didn't listen to me now I have to tell you, tsk tsk
Well, all five contestants were to do 2 songs all in one hour so they knew there was gong to be a time crunch. Because of this, the judges were not going to say anything after the first performances and then critique both songs after the 2nd. Well, for some unknown reason Ryan changes it and has the contestants come on stage after they all finished their first songs and the judges werent' ready. When it was Paula's turn she started out with Jason's first song and then went on to comment on his 2nd
Well, of course she soon was informed that he hadn't yet sung his 2nd song she quickly said oh, that was her notes for David C. Although her commnet on Jason's 2nd song was a big negative (for Paula) she gave David C a glowing critique on what was supposidly the same performance....so then there was all this debate on why that happened which I think you've heard something about.
what I should do is just see if I can find it on Youtube-and you can still see for yourself.