I read that earlier in the day and was disgusted about that. However, he has a right to give his opinion just like I do also. I dont think anyone in their right mind would say Nalbandian should not be in the top 3. Nalbandian and Safin should be fighting for #1 with Federer IMO. They are that talented. Nalbandian has all tools needed, but a great serve, to beat anybody.
I also think based on results, Ljubicic should be where he is right now. He is definitely more than a serve. He has a good volley, a consistent backhand, improved forehand, variety and more importantly, belief. If PMac thinks Roddick should be in the top 5, that I disagree with. Gone are the days when you can just dominate with the serve.
Roddick has just too many facets to improve upon. What disgusts me when I see him play of late is the low confidence coupled with the bad implementation of his biggest weapon, the serve. Many times, he has an opponent pulled far wide with the kick serve and he waits for the ball to be returned into his side of the court before pulling the trigger. By then, his advantage is already neutralized. Add to that the problem with his backhand and movement. Then, he should not belong in the top 5 IMO. Just too many facets to exploit.
My top 5 right now, should everyone play to their potential will be Roger, Safin, Nalbandian, Blake and Nadal. It's all subjective though but that's the way I see it.