Originally Posted by Mountaindewslave
Roddick has world #1 ranking, a bunch of GS finals, bunch of Master 1000 titles, played in a better era (yes Federer's prime years were more competitive / higher quality than today)
Roddick won a title every year from 2001-2012
Roddick was a great player
Roddick is hugely underrated on this forum and in general
Roddick is a prime example of a great player under-performing although much of this was the fault of Federer
Didn't you noticed I said "achievements aside"?
Achievements aside, I'd say Del Potro is the best player. I can see him doing better than Roddick had they've been peers in the Federer/Hewitt/Safin/Nalbandian era.
What does Roddick has on Del Potro beside the serve? I'm all ears.