Federer is obviously more likely to win the tournament. Peak Federer won the tournament 4 times (discounting 2008). Peak Nadull has won it once or twice, depending on whether this is still his peak. Federer is a far greater player at the US Open.
In a match between them, however, Nadal will always have a good shot on an outdoor hard court, & judging by their H2H, a decisive edge.
Does this really need a thread?
Best post so far.
Rafa has a decisive edge if it's a one-on-one face off.If it's a tournament though,Fed has the better shot.