In terms of win% I think Murray's is slightly better.
But my poor phrasing has led you astray, I meant his record against people ranked 3-10(obviously at the time he played them) wasn't good not his record against "FEDAL".
yes, now i took a look at their h2h and yes Murray is not slightly but quite better, against fedal, however if anyone starts to analyze how many encounters Novak has had with Fedal, about 2.5x more than Murray, and the number of times both of them played nadal or even fed on clay, numbers, i think would start to look not so convincing
and yes i misunderstood you, i thought you were referring to no.1 and 2
and to be honest i never had that kind of impression, that he was not
so good against top 3-10
he's 0-1 against donkey
that the DC retirement
he's 3-3 against David, (3-2 prior from 2007)
he's 2-1 agaist the duck
Blake he only meet once ! 1-0
he's 2-1 against nalby
2-1 against gasquet (all in 2007 or prior when Richie was top10)
0-1 against Simon
1-2 against Tsonga
1-2 against Gonzo
and the best for the last
4-2 against Murray
but lately it looks like his little baby pigeon got away
all in all it's not so bad
but we both can agree that his wins over top 10 are on a much important stages and in bigger events than his losses.
but all this is not quite convincing either, and that what it's all about with djokovic, consistency is something he is yet to achieve, or not.
But if the first occurs, he will have a clearly better carrier than Murray, for now it's just my hunch-how can it be anything more than that, when we are at the very start of their rivalry.