I don't care about this silly little debate but this is obviously wrong. Dimitrov's started working with some proper coaches and part of the reason he's reached his first final is because he's played correctly.
And anyway, it is too really to give a proper assessment of these two as tennis players. They've haven't done anything of note outside of Tomic's QF run and that was back in 2011.
Not QF, but last year, in AO, the same Tomic lost in round previous to QF and only to the GOAT.
If he wins today and reach 3rd round in AO, he will even gain places in the ranks, with very few to defend in the rest of year. Specially on Wimby, where he can improve HUGELY in the ranks, since he lost 1st round last year.