Rafa was great as usually on clay season in 2011. Still (peak) Nole won all their clay meetings, and would have won RG final unless he he had Roger in semi, Roger is worse match-up for Nole than Rafa. This year we saw only the average Nole, and that showed average Nole loses to Rafa.
that's just false. Nadal 2011 clay was not anywhere near his clay levels from 2005-2008. if you were at all aware of what it is like to play on clay court conditions, you would understand that a huge part of it is movement. Nadal did not move in 2011 anywhere near as well as he did when he was younger, and the fact is his clay game was a bit off the whole season. he even struggled some against Federer in the RG final. not to say Federer didn't play well, but it is a strong indication that Nadal was off of his best. he might never go back to his best on clay, but for a fact he was not near it in the past few seasons
only a clown takes two matches in a players career that he happens to win, labels them as that players prime on a surface, etc. that's retarded, so Djokovic for a few tournaments of his clay career reached prime level but the rest of his career has evaded it?
combination of mediocre Nadal and a few good matches on clay for Djokovic and nothing more. the reality check is that it was all in their brains, with Nadal having a weird struggle mentally with Nole in 2011.
I've never heard someone claim something so stupid as that Djokovic's clay prime is anywhere near as good as Nadal's until now, so thank you for making me realize how retarded some people in the world can be.