So according to Nadaltards, this win will come with a * since the winner did not defeat Nadal...
Which nadaltards said that ? I'd love for you to point that out since I obviously missed that part in this thread as well other threads including the ''Would Murray's GS be tainted?'' thread. If nadaltards said that, it's quite sad or they are trolling but I have a feeling you made that up.
As far as the thread goes i'm surprised it didn't happen sooner. I guess that speaks volumes of Federers superb consistency to be nearly always playing a semi in nearly every GS.