I didn't see the first set but second and third were wildly entertaining (and I don't particularly like bomb-fests). I'd have been ticked if I'd lost a set after only losing four points on my own serve like Andy did.
Crappy foot-fault call (I didn't notice any TV-replay to confirm or deny) in the Isner service game prior to his final one. But Andy should have gotten a warning for the racquet toss. Guess the chair was giving a little leeway since John took too long to change his socks. LOL. Stupid TV though, putting a clock on that adventure. Plenty of other guys on tour waste way more than that (over the course of the match) just preparing to serve.
Still, I thought both guys served well, Roddick had just a bit better groundies and net play. Am looking forward to seeing the two of them in doubs at the Olympics.