I agree with your picks. I also think the Federer-Roddick Wimbledon 09 final is very much overrated. Federer was not really at his best. Sure Roddick held like 30 something consecutive games but Federer was returning very poorly and his normal passing shots were not on. Roddick was playing great but his volleys didn't improve so much all of a sudden that Federer was unable to make a single good pass.
Mate, I saw your username and I was convinced you were going to disagree with my first pick.
But yeah, the Wimbledon 2009 final is overrated. The quality of the serving was great, but like the 2008 final, there weren't a huge number of memorable moments.
I sometimes feel that people are too eager to call a match a classic just because it goes to 5 sets. They seem to forget that a match can go 5 sets and still be very ordinary.