Why is Djokovic number 2 for you, Clay Death? Has he reached the SF once and come close to winning it 3 times? (Davydenko)
Or even more embarrassingly, Federer destroyed and bagelled the Clay Monster on his own surface and has reached the French Open SF once and FINAL TWICE and yet he's number 5?
And Federer has had a horrible year thus far for his standards, so how do you justify putting him so high? This thread is asking for people's opinions, and as you expect to be able to express yours, let other people express theirs.