You seem to have forgotten the 2007 AO semifinal, it was almost even more magical than the 2004 US Open final!!
Roddick got his tactics wrong in that match, with disastrous results.
There will come a time - not too far away now - when Fed comes into a GS final (other than the French) in good form, but simply gets beaten all ends up and goes down in straight sets. That happened to Pete at the USO 2000. I think Fed probably has another two years before it happens to him, but it's on the way.