I hope I've been here long enough that I can share my ideas to make this place better
I hope I don't offend any moderators or Andreas and Snowwy with this proposal.
, since I feel that I have annoyed him/her way too much with my PMs.
. I sincerely apologize.)
But here it is:
Basically, this new structure will be a lot more flexible, and easier for Moderators and Administrators to manage.
On top of that, it will hopefully be a lot more fair for the punished members because it will give them the opportunity to clean up their acts
, and at the same time will be tougher, because it will constantly ban the most terrible member
This will give the banned members a lot more chances to come back - which is backhanded, because it will give the moderators an easier time to ban them over and over again.
New Warning System
Should now be a Reminder or a Pre-Warning.
Will not be worth anything, but it should indicate that a particular member should be more considerate of the rules in this board.
Red Cards (Infractions):
Should now be accumulated to 10.
A member will be banned when they collect 10 Red Cards (Infractions).
Everytime a user collects 10 Red Cards, they will be banned for 30 days.
Each infraction is worth how much offense it carries:
For a light offense - 1 Red Card, expire in 1 month
For a moderate offense - 2 Red Cards, expire in 2 months
For a heavy offense - 3 or more Red Cards, expire in 3 months or more.
Why is this fair?
Because this will avoid 90% of Permanent Bans cases. This is fair for both terms because if a member breaks a lot of rules, he will accumulate 10 very fast and will be on a ban for 30 days. He comes back after his 30-day ban, he decides to break more rules, and that will definitely accumulate him another 10 points for another 30-day ban. And so on. This is much easier to manage because the most terrible members will be constantly banned, but at the same time will give them chances to come back to this board and hopefully they'll clean up their acts.
The only way a member will be Permanently banned if all the moderators and administrators agree that they need to be.
Basically, everyone gets a fair treatment.
Why is this flexible?
Because as I mentioned, it's a standard for all platforms, and a standard all across the MTF board. I reviewed the new ban lengths
and I thought that it is way too complicated, especially for each type of category there is a sub category. Like a different expiry date for each red card, and on top of that, it will be another different expiry date for the next red card of the same category.
With this new system, it will be a one easy formula to dispense members who are breaking all the rules. And at the same time, it will be more lenient as it will take 10 infractions for a 30 day ban.
Instead of different ban lengths, why can't we keep it a whole 30-day ban whenever a member reaches 10 infraction points?
So here it is. I hope I can share my ideas to this board.
Have a good night!