What I don't agree with, was the fact that he was practically witchhunted after he came back despite his obvious change of tone. It was like the mods just waited breathlessly for him to make a mistake to permaban him.
I remember that I and also some other users weren't satisfied with the justification of the permaban in the banned users thread. "Was warned after coming back of a 1-yr-ban, broke rules again." Which rule? What did he do? We didn't get an answer to that until now. At this point the communication about Feldman's ban is better, that doesn't change the fact that the ban is ridiculous considering the post he was eventually banned for.