Puyol can't play a full season these days. He's still top 5 when fit and healthy, but not a full time player anymore if it makes sense.
I hesitated between Mata and Silva there, ended up picking Silva but could easily have gone for Mata, they're on the same level imo.
If we include all-time, then Safin and Ancic would be in my list
True, which is a shame because i really like Puyol. Pepe just seems too much of a loose cannon for me though.
I would agree that Mata & Silva are on the same level pretty much but Mata edges it imo. He grabs more goals, and assists and is more influential to his team than Silva
Anyway, what do you make of Vidal? I'm a big fan of his.
On to tennis, Who would you place them ahead in your favourites list?