I agree. Murray wasn't great in the USO early rounds, he has definitely played better elsewhere and he's certainly a very good player. But the SF and F of USO '12 just left me cold, it was dreadful to watch and (presumably) to play in.
I don't expect Murray fans to agree but it was a shambolic end to an otherwise enjoyable tournament.
When you've stuck with a fave for 8 years and suffered a few moments of heartache you'll take it any way you can.
You're a Nole fan you'd probably agree the Wimbledon he won was pretty low quality (with a DIRE final for grass tennis) but he still got the W no one will change that.