unusually I fully disagree with that. I don't know if I've already said it but imo Djokovic and Murray played two great matches against each other : their last two ones of the year.
I also don't get the fancy for Nadal-Rosol match, Gulbis-Berdych was better imo, and Fed-Benneteau was quite near and had more interesting tennis imo.
I also think Tsonga-Djokovic in the FO is overrated although it was surely a very entertaining match.
I agree on all except the Djokeray one at the A.O., which I think you're seriously underrating. Nadal-Rosol produced at least 15 minutes of very entertaining highlights but it's more a case of one of the greatest 5th-set performances on serve rather than a great match.