Originally Posted by evilmindbulgaria
Oh, really? RG'06,07,08,11 AO'09 WI'08 were not all Nadal - Federer finals? How many more chances does the supposed "Goat" need?
I think the point is that not many finals that Federer lost were played out in Federer's prime of 2003-2007. In fact, I count only 4 total finals between these two, with 2 Wimbledons to Federer and 2 French Opens to Nadal.
What would have been interesting is if Nadal was the same age as Federer.