Murray probably played his best match ever vs Nadal at the US Open back in 2008 yet he still didn't deserve a place in the final?
Jason come on man ... he almost lost to Melzer and struggled against Llodra....and del Potro had a break up in all the sets I think
. And that was pretty obvious because he got thrashed by Fed in the final
. Fed did play pretty good though, but still, if Muza was in any good form there, he would have made it a bit more competitive.
Anyways I think he played better against Rafa in AO'10, because I truly think that despite Rafa struggling with his form, Murray was clearly the better player and deserved to win that. But I ain't saying he didn't deserve his SF win in US'08, just saying he needed a bit of luck to get through that one is all